Radical Washtenaw received Chief DeGiusti’s response to our report, “Why Are Black People in Ypsilanti Disproportionately Arrested on Bench Warrants?” We appreciate that DeGiusti took some time to attempt to address some of the questions raised in the RAW report via his memo to City Manager Ralph Lange, dated February 22, 2016. Here are some problems with the memo.
- Rhetorical arguments which skirt the questions of the RAW report and further the lack of transparency around police practices.
In his memo, DeGiusti argues that the RAW report does not prove anything; he does not disprove any of RAW’s claims, however. Instead, DeGiusti makes several rhetorical arguments, but unfortunately he does not provide any additional numeric data which, he claims “would take a vast amount of staff time” to obtain. RAW was very transparent about the limitations of the publicly-available data and about the need for cooperation from the police departments, courts, and county to obtain more accurate and comprehensive data. The Chief has access to relevant data that could go a long way towards clarifying the situation, yet he does not provide it.
Continue reading →